Thomas Unise
Art forgery has a long history dating back centuries, but modern technology is now providing new tools for fraudsters. According to recent reporting by the Financial Times, generative AI tools are increasingly being used to create fake provenance documents that authenticate fraudulent artwork.
How AI Is Changing Art Forgery
While Michelangelo once used acidic loam to age his forgeries, today’s fraudsters are turning to AI to create convincing documentation. Fine art broker Olivia Eccleston of Marsh McClennan told the Financial Times that chatbots and large language models are helping criminals forge sales invoices, valuations, provenance documents, and certificates of authenticity with unprecedented ease.
Provenance—the documented history of ownership that establishes a work’s authenticity—is now being falsified through AI-generated papers that can be difficult to distinguish from legitimate documentation. In one case, an insurance adjuster received dozens of seemingly convincing certificates for a large painting collection, only to discover through metadata analysis that the entire collection was fake.
Unintentional Fraud Through AI Hallucinations
Interestingly, not all AI-related fraud is intentional. The Financial Times notes that some collectors have unwittingly contributed to the problem by using AI to research provenance information. When queried about artwork history, AI systems sometimes “hallucinate” or fabricate convincing but entirely fictional provenance details. An analyst at art research firm Flynn and Giovani described AI as “quite conniving” because “it has to come up with an answer, so if you give it enough information, it will guess something.”
The Growing Challenge for Authenticators
While insurance adjusters and art authenticators are also employing AI tools to detect forgeries, they’re finding it increasingly difficult to keep pace with the sophistication of AI-generated fakes. Grace Best-Devereux, a claims adjuster at Sedgwick, expressed concern that we’re reaching a “precipice where it might not be possible” to visually identify suspicious documentation that warrants further investigation.
The ease with which fraudsters can now create highly probable-looking documents presents a significant challenge for the art world, potentially undermining centuries of authentication practices and threatening market integrity.
The Historical Context
Art forgery is nothing new—the article opens with the example of Michelangelo creating a fake Roman sculpture fragment in 1496 when he was just 21 years old. However, AI tools have dramatically lowered the barrier to entry for potential fraudsters while simultaneously making detection more difficult.
Key Takeaways
The rise of AI-assisted art fraud represents a significant evolution in an age-old problem, combining traditional deception with cutting-edge technology. As AI continues to advance, the art world faces increasing challenges in maintaining the integrity of provenance documentation and authentication processes.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings